GM John Lynch traded back several times in Pittsburgh, made eight picks, and the players he selected baffled many.

Addressing the concerns, Lynch made it clear he's having none of it, telling reporters, "We've got consensus in this building, that's the consensus I care about."

49ers draft 2026: What did San Francisco do? 

Much of the criticism centres around San Francisco's early picks. They took wide receiver De'Zhaun Stribling at 33, edge rusher Romello Height at 70 and running back Kaelon Black at 90.

With Christian McCaffrey already on the roster and Mike Evans and Christian Kirk signed in free agency, it wasn't quite what draftniks had pencilled in for the Niners.

ESPN analyst Mel Kiper Jr. didn't hold back on his evaluation of the Stribling selection. "He was No. 73 on my board and the No. 12 wideout. Denzel Boston? Germie Bernard? Antonio Williams? I had a half-dozen receivers who made more sense in that spot."

For context, NFL analyst Daniel Jeremiah had Stribling ranked 63rd overall, and The Athletic's Dane Brugler ranked him as the 11th-best wideout in the class and 67th overall.

The Black selection raised the most eyebrows. Brugler had the Indiana tailback ranked 179th overall. Bear in mind, once again, that San Francisco took him with the 90th pick.

Once again, Lynch pushed back, sharing why he's excited to add Black to the roster.

How does the 49ers draft haul compare with other teams?

Every year, a player comes out of nowhere to defy their pre-draft ranking and become a valuable contributor to their new team. Plenty of "reaches" have gone on to prove everyone wrong.

With that said, sorry Niners fans, but the early verdict isn't pretty.

Lynch addresses draft "reaches"

Sports Illustrated's 49ers reporter Grant Cohn put it to John Lynch and Kyle Shanahan directly after the draft concluded.

Lynch's response was direct, and head coach Kyle Shanahan had his back.

AI in the 49ers' draft room

Lynch recently revealed the team has been leaning on artificial intelligence as part of the draft process.

"If you aren’t using it, you’re already behind. The cool thing is, what we’ve found, you don’t need to be an expert," he told reporters during the pre-draft press conference.

"I think we’re fortunate to be where we are kind of at the epicenter of the innovation there, and we’ve tried to take advantage of that," he added.

How much AI is actually shaping their decisions is anyone's guess, but Lynch may be judged on this comment if this class doesn't deliver.

My take on the 49ers' draft

For now, Lynch gets a pass because he's found some real gems in previous drafts.

That group, headlined by George Kittle in Round 5 of the 2017 NFL Draft, and Brock Purdy with the final selection of the 2022 Draft, were as impressive value picks as any in recent history.

Mitchell Leff / Stringer

Moreover, despite dealing with a litany of long-term injuries to star players in 2025, the 49ers still held their own in the most competitive division in football and made the playoffs for the fifth time in the last seven years.

Yes, none of those postseason trips has resulted in a Vince Lombardi, but if that's the measure by which we judge a general manager, 31 others have fallen short, too.

With that said, there's no argument that San Francisco's recent draft classes have fallen short, and Lynch and Co. will be held accountable if the upcoming season - and the 2026 Draft class - don't work out as the GM envisaged.